________________________________________________________________________ SPECTROPOP - Spectacular! Retro! Pop! ________________________________________________________________________ There are 25 messages in this issue. Topics in this digest: 1. Re: Disco & computers ? From: Stewart Mason 2. Re: Beatles From: Clark Besch 3. Re: Looking for Mob cd or songs for dad? From: Clark Besch 4. Re: Shortest track of all time From: Andres 5. Re: Shortest track of all time From: Eddy 6. Re: Beatles - Born Too Late From: Clark Besch 7. Re: the very last day From: Clark Besch 8. Bee Gees & White Soul From: James Botticelli 9. Re: Japanese Bubblegum CDs From: Orion 10. Re: One hit wonders and bucking the trends. From: Paul Bryant 11. Re: 4 Seasons' "Gazette" From: Paul Bryant 12. Re: Shortest track of all time From: Paul Bryant 13. The first Disco record From: Justin McDevitt 14. Re: Shortest Track of all time/Short elpees From: Steven Prazak 15. born too early From: Alan Zweig 16. Re: Shortest track of all time From: Tom Taber 17. Bob Gaudio From: Stuart Miller 18. Re: House Of The Rising Sun From: Harold Shackelford 19. Tim Rice and "Disco" From: Michael Edwards 20. Version Galore. From: Julio Niño 21. Re: Bubblegum CDs From: Kim Cooper 22. Re: Disco CD comps From: David Parkinson 23. Re: The Wild Ones / Chip Taylor From: Phil Milstein 24. Modern Doo Wop From: Kingsley Abbott 25. Re: Shortest track of all time From: Joe Nelson ________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________ Message: 1 Date: Tue, 25 Nov 2003 23:16:02 -0800 (PST) From: Stewart Mason Subject: Re: Disco & computers ? Bill Brown wrote: > A record cannot truly be called "disco" unless there was some computer > programming involved in the production. Are you counting all synthesizers as computers? (Because analogue synths weren't computers, and therefore by your logic, the first disco records came out around 1982.) Or are you just thinking in terms of electronic drums and sequencers? If the latter, you might be surprised to learn that they weren't used as often in disco records as you might think. For example, that amazingly precise lockstep beat that underpins the entirety of Donna Summer's "Love To Love You Baby" -- which I'm sure you'll agree was a disco record -- comes courtesy of Keith Forsey's left foot. Those are live drums, but deliberately played without the inflection that an Earl Palmer or a Bernard Purdie would give them. I've often assumed that producer Giorgio Moroder was influenced on some level by the German progressive band Neu!, whose use of an unchanging, uninflected 4/4 beat was their sonic trademark. Stewart -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 2 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 07:19:16 -0000 From: Clark Besch Subject: Re: Beatles Mike McKay wrote: > But my most memorable "first Beatle hearing" was "Strawberry Fields > Forever." I was a big fan of Dick Summer's "Nite Lite" show on WBZ > Boston, and I stayed up way late on a school night (at least 1:00 or > 2:00 a.m.) to hear his promised first airing of it. When I heard the > false ending, with the backwards mellotron coming back in, I was > positively psychedelicized! I can truthfully say that this moment had > a profound effect on me...it was like nothing was gonna be the same > from that point forward. Mike, Exactly what I am speaking of. I can often remember the dates of songs by my radio tapes and what I was doing the moment I recorded the song!! I'd love to hear your Beatles hour on WKYC tape! I heard Dick Summer's show too, but not often in Dodge City, Kansas. He had a lot of fun for a laid back voice and altho he came off underground, he often played pop stuff on his shows as well. Personally, I taped "Strawberry Fields" first off WLS with Ron Riley commenting over the "return ending", "isn't that ending the wierdest, huh?". How true! -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 3 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 07:11:28 -0000 From: Clark Besch Subject: Re: Looking for Mob cd or songs for dad? Chris wrote: > Hi there, I just recently came across this board. Here's my question. > With Christmas coming up I'm looking for something really good to get > him. He always talks about growing up listening to The Mob. He went > to a few of their shows, and said that they were one of the best > bands to see live. He's been looking for years for a cd of the Mob or > even a cd with just any of their songs. SO basically I'm trying to > find a cd/record with The Mob songs on it. The important ones, "I Dig > everything about you" and " Give it to me"! So if anyone knows a > place where I could order this cd or any info at all would be very > helpful. Thanks. Chris, If our own James Holvay is listening (Reading?), he was a leading member of the Mob! He co-wrote essentially all their original material including the 2 hits you mentioned. If James doesn't answer you, email me off line and maybe I can help you out. Clark -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 4 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 11:50:03 +0300 From: Andres Subject: Re: Shortest track of all time Mike McKay: > Now, would anyone like to make nominations for the shortest *track* > of all time? (Warning: somewhat of a trick question!) Nutopia - six seconds of silence (track 6) from John Lennon's Mind Games LP. -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 5 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 09:22:07 +0100 From: Eddy Subject: Re: Shortest track of all time Mike McKay asked: > Now, would anyone like to make nominations for the shortest *track* > of all time? (Warning: somewhat of a trick question!) Lennon...Nutopian National Anthem ? Eddy -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 6 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 07:26:27 -0000 From: Clark Besch Subject: Re: Beatles - Born Too Late Paul Bryant wrote: > ...I often wonder how young music fans regard the huge mass of great > stuff from (let's say) the 60s and 70s. I myself had to catch up on > the good 50s stuff, but I was only a decade behind - what if you were > starting out today?! The mind boggles. Thing is, with us "old timers" who lived it, we continue (thru S'pop and research and friends) to discover lost 60's gems all the time. I don't think I'll ever run dry of 60's material to search for! It's just nice to know the more familiar stuff from first hand knowledge! Clark -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 7 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 07:33:28 -0000 From: Clark Besch Subject: Re: the very last day Phil Milstein wrote: > I heard a generic cover version the other day of a song I recognize, > but cannot quite place who I know it by. It's called "The Very Last > Day." A Google search shows a prominent version by The Hollies, but > I don't know if that's the one I'm familiar with. Anyone else cut > this one? I know I'll feel like a dope once the answers start coming > in, but that's never stopped me before. Certainly the Hollies' version was a hit in Europe. I am thinking a few acts covered this, but if you heard it on radio, I can't imagine it even being the Hollies unless you are in Europe. In the US, I believe I have a version by the Grasshoppers, a midwest band, but I can't imagine you heard this one either. Great song, no matter who does it! Clark -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 8 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 06:24:31 -0500 From: James Botticelli Subject: Bee Gees & White Soul Phil Milstein wrote: > Has there ever been a song written and originally recorded by white > artists that was more accepted as authentically black than "To Love > Somebody"? The acceptance of this song among the soul elite has to > have been one of the great thrills of the Bee Gees' career. The Magnificent Men on Capitol were very soulful. "Peace of Mind" ranks right up there with the great group ballads of the late 6T's. Both vocally and instrumentally, arrangement-wise. Then there are The Righteous Brothers who sound like The Knight Brothers. More later if the thread has legs. -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 9 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 8:07:40 -0500 From: Orion Subject: Re: Japanese Bubblegum CDs One thing for sure, these CDs are harder than ever to get ahold of. There is someone on ebay selling them again. Oddly, enough this person and supposedly this person's friend are the only people I have ever seen sell them. If anyone has any place to get them other than from Hairlessspider on ebay please let me know. Indeed there are some great songs on these CDs. Because of them I have purchased several LPs "Main Attraction", "Silver", "Good N Plenty" and many others because of one song. I have not been disappointed by the LPs. Orion -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 10 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 02:41:05 -0800 (PST) From: Paul Bryant Subject: Re: One hit wonders and bucking the trends. Steve Harvey wrote: > Of course there have been lots of one hit wonders. My point is that > disco rarely spawned acts that survived past a couple of hits. This is quite right, but how about the weird example of the very horrible disco act Boney M - they didn't have all that many hits, but two of the hits they did have are in the UK all-time best selling singles top ten! pb -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 11 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 05:10:09 -0800 (PST) From: Paul Bryant Subject: Re: 4 Seasons' "Gazette" Richard Hattersley wrote: > Why do you think "American Crucifixion" is an embarrassment > by the way? To me it stands out as being as musically > inventive as the rest of the album. It's because it has a really REALLY horrible main tune which is like nails scraped along a blackboard, sung in a particularly unconvincing way; it also seems to be a lame addition to the operatic pop attempts of the time - Macarthur Park and its follow-ups being the big daddies, then things like Eloise by Paul & Barry Ryan, Excerpt from a Teenage Opera and many album tracks too. And finally, the whole album is straining mightily to be "relevant" like Bob Gaudio said to himself - uh oh, the Seasons are beginning to sound old hat, better get hip with this protest stuff. So he went to see The Graduate and heard Pleasant Valley Sunday and created an album whose main target seems to be the hypocrisy of middle-class American parents, which is a soft target if ever there was one. There are some cracking songs on the album but my goodness there's some bad ones too! By the way - I managed to get myself a CD of this by trading with a guy in Australia. So if anyone's interested drop me a line off list. pb -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 12 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 05:13:31 -0800 (PST) From: Paul Bryant Subject: Re: Shortest track of all time Dan Hughes wrote: > Even a silent track lasts a particular amount of > time, so one silent track could be shorter than another. > I know of two silent tracks: > 1. The album WCPAEB 3 (West Coast Pop Art Experimental > Band), from about 1968, had a silent track that ran several > minutes entitled "Anniversary of World War III." Get it? > 2. A silent single--three minutes of silence if I remember > correctly--was available for jukeboxes at the beginning of > the rock and roll era so that diners who hated the music could > have a few minutes' respite. "Three Glorious Minutes of Silence" > or something similar was the title. May have done well in > restaurants, but can you imagine Casey playing it in his > countdown show if it sold enough to make the charts? Love it! There's jolly old John Lennon's Nutoptian National Anthem on Mind Games, I believe that's 3 seconds of silence. But various British Death Metal (or whatever their mini-genre is) bands have recorded songs allegedly 1 second long, so it's going to be hard to beat those. pb -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 13 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 07:40:21 -0600 From: Justin McDevitt Subject: The first Disco record Hello Spectropop, For me, disco will always be linked with the mid to late 70s, as a definitive sound which incorporated elements of pop and "soulmusic", yet had its own distinct sound and rhythm/beat. Disco was also a cultural phenomenon, defined by the venues in which it was played and danced to, the clothes, the lighting, the whole 70s, pre-Aids singles scene. A further defining component of the Disco sound was the instrumentation which blended strings, horns and the requisite bass and background guitar, along with various types of synthesizers whose integration into rock and progressive music, (though fairly recent) was fairly well established. All this being said, my choice for the first Disco record is 1974's Jive Talk by the Bee Gees. Rock The Boat, by the Hughes Corporation, (also from the summer of 1974) is a very close second. Justin McDevitt -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 14 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 09:25:01 -0500 From: Steven Prazak Subject: Re: Shortest Track of all time/Short elpees I seem to recall a "tune" by '70s band Mason Prophet called, if memory serves, Apple Tart that lasted for one mighty solitary second. Another short album was Capitol's Beatles Story, inexplicably a double album set, with side 4 clocking in at an anemic 9 minutes. Amusingly enough, the Japanese CD re-ish from the '80s is also a 2-CD set. Steven Prazak Atlanta -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 15 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 09:53:17 -0500 From: Alan Zweig Subject: born too early Martin Jensen (Re: Beatles - Born Too Late) > Well, I can answer that. I was born in 1980 and began to pay > serious interest to the 60s after going through the obligatory > 'Beatles-phase' as a 14-year old. ('obligatory' meaning something > that I guess EVERYONE during or since the hey-day of the fab four > have gone through at some point in their life.) > For me, the cool thing about investigating music of the 60s and > 70s has been the way one thing leads to another: from the Beatles > you eventually go on to other great Britsh groups like the Zombies > and the Kinks, from the Beach Boys to the Association and Mark Eric, > from Spector to Nitzsche, Bono or Tempo and so on. There's no better > feeling than tracing the influence of a cool genre or group, and in > the process discovering some great songs, artists or groups. Maybe somebody already made this point but just because you were born "on time" to hear the music of the sixties, didn't mean you did. Myself, I'm sure I've heard more in the last few years, through reissues mostly, than I heard during the actual sixties. It's true that if you were alive back then, there were a couple of artists like the Beatles or the Stones or Dylan that you got the experience of anticipating the next record and hearing the changes. And that was fun. But it's not necessarily true that "being there" leads to the greater understanding or the greater enjoyment. Sometimes you can be standing too close. I know that none of you youngsters are exactly saying "I wish I'd been alive back then" but people do say things like that and though I understand it, it also seems counterintuitive to me. I remember this guy about my age who told me that he wished he'd been born in the forties instead of the fifties so that he could have bought doowop singles when they came out and paid a lot less than he did later in the late sixties (and beyond) when he got into that music. I tried to tell him that if he'd been born in the forties, there's no guarantee he would have gotten into doowop. Especially given the fact that in the late sixties, he got into doowop and ignored all the "psychedelic" stuff of the day. He didn't seem to understand what I was saying. But then he made my point for me by informing me that he'd gone to Woodstock but ONLY to see Sha-na-na. AZ -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 16 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 07:03:16 -0800 (PST) From: Tom Taber Subject: Re: Shortest track of all time I remember toying with the idea of issuing a "Disco version" of the Lennon-Ono silent cut on a 12 inch 45, and I believe some other sicko might have actually done it! The shortest track I know of is (hope I get the name right!) "Magic Melody Part 2" by Les Paul and Mary Ford. Supposedly some DJs complained because the original, which scraped the bottom of the charts in '55, seemed to be missing the final two notes, which are the "two bits" part of "shave and a haircut." (If I've lost Andres again, I apologize - his English skills are better than many of the people I deal with every day.) So Capitol put out a DJ 45 with just those two notes, and it's maybe 2 seconds long. I found my copy by accident on Ebay, and at the $8.00 or so I paid for it, it's the most expensive per second record I've ever purchased! Tom Taber -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 17 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 15:08:36 -0000 From: Stuart Miller Subject: Bob Gaudio Frank wrote: > While I can't comment on the record you are referring to I can > comment on the record sleeve. It is a take-off of the Four Seasons > album "Genuine Imitation Life Gazette", also produced by Bob Gaudio, > which predates "Thick As A Brick" by a couple of years. I know of > another record released on this label, "Buena Vista" by a > group/artist called Light, this too produced by Gaudio. The Gazette > label was a Bob Gaudio venture to promote new artists. While I don't > know just how many records were released on this label I feel safe in > saying the number was small. Frank, I had no idea there had been a Gazette label. Can you tell me when it was set up and who distributed it? Also, any ideas about how many records it issued? with thanks Stuart -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 18 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 07:22:55 -0800 (PST) From: Harold Shackelford Subject: Re: House Of The Rising Sun Bill George wrote: > ..."House Of The Rising Sun".... > I always liked the Jody Miller version. The Supremes version of "House Of The Rising Sun" from the 1964 Motown LP "A Bit Of Liverpool" is my nomination for the most unnecessary version to be sung to date. -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 19 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 16:10:12 -0000 From: Michael Edwards Subject: Tim Rice and "Disco" I recall that when Tim Rice used to broadcast on London's Capital Radio in the 70s, he once stated that disco started with two records: George McCrae's "Rock Your Baby" and William DeVaughan's "Be Thankful For What You Got". "Rock Your Baby" has already received a nod on this site but it's the full-length version you want with the keyboard playing of Harry Casey (of KC & The Sunshine Band fame) taking up the last two or three minutes. I wasn't sure about "Be Thankful For What You Got" as I thought it was too slow. It did reach number 1 R&B and number 4 pop in 1974. Twenty years later it showed up on Massive Attack's first album, "Blue Line". I'm still not sure whether or not you can dance to it, but it says a lot about Mr. Rice's ability to pick 'em. Incidentally, another radio personality, Miami talk-show host, Neil Rogers always preferred KC & The Sunshine Band to Gloria Estafan and the Miami Sound Machine when discussing local Miami music. KC duetted with Teri DeSario on a great revival of Barbara Mason's "Yes I'm Ready" in 1979, which allows me to segue into the Bee Gees as Barry Gibb wrote Teri DeSario's pop-disco classic, "Ain't Nothing Gonna Keep Me From You". Released on Casablanca Records in 1978, this wonderful piece of pop confection was produced by Denny Randell and is another quality notch in the songwriting belt of Mr. Gibb. Mike -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 20 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 16:11:43 -0000 From: Julio Niño Subject: Version Galore. Don said: > Didn't Karina do a version of "Will You Love Me Tomorrow"? > It was called either "Querrás Amarme Mañana" or "Me Querrás > Mañana". If you have that, I would love it if you could play > to musica. Don, Yes , I have that Track, "¿ Querrás amarme mañana? "(Will You Love Me Tomorrow?) by Karina. It´s included in a 1974 LP. Of course I can play it in musica, but I must say that it is quite a horrendous cover, in a pseudo reggae style (talking of reggae, you sure know the versions of "Will you love me tomorrow?" made by the Jamaican singers Slim Smith and Dave Baker in the sixties, both are very good). If you are still interested and dare to listen to karina's version and want to judge for yourself, let me know. Much more interesting, in my opinion, are some French versions, mentioned in your "Wish list" That I've listened to, like "Fiere de Toi" by Audrey ("Walking Proud" ), the wonderful "Mon Ami" ("Where Do I Go") by Silvie Vartan, "Tu la revois" ("He's In Town") and "Et Quelque Chose Me Dit" ("I'm Into Something Good") by Ria Bartock, and the latter also by Richard Anthony, or "Reviendra T'il Encore" (Will you love me tomorrow?) by Jocelyne. Julio Niño. -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 21 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 09:03:41 -0800 From: Kim Cooper Subject: Re: Bubblegum CDs Patrick, Scout's honor, the "Bubblegum Music is the Naked Truth" folks are not responsible for the "Bubblegum M*****f****r" CD series... at least, the editorial staff ain't. And if one of the contributors is involved, they've kept it verrry quiet. Kim -- Scram PO Box 461626 Hollywood, CA 90046-1626 http://www.scrammagazine.com Scram #18 out now with Emitt Rhodes, the Ramones, Marty Thau, Smoosh and more. -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 22 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 09:02:37 -0800 From: David Parkinson Subject: Re: Disco CD comps Phil Milstein wrote: > A great point. Which leads me to wonder if there aren't any CD > comps of early/obscure disco -- really good collections, I mean James Botticelli: > A really good representative sample of early and not well known are > the two David Mancuso compilations called "The Loft" named after > the storied gay underground club in early 7T's NYC. Another excellent CD is "Larry Levan Live at the Paradise Garage", a double CD on Strut Records from the UK. It was taken straight off the mixing board on one night in 1979, and sounds fantastic. You will not be able to NOT shake your booty when it plays. Also, another interesting collection of trax is found on the Soul Jazz CD "Philadelphia Roots", which covers that period which I really love, where Philly soul is morphing into disco. Thos David Mancuso things are interesting also, but perhaps a bit too eclectic to classify as "disco". David -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 23 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 12:06:27 +0000 From: Phil Milstein Subject: Re: The Wild Ones / Chip Taylor Susan Hilton wrote: > Yes, that's the band, I was just reading about this in the liners to > From Nowhere, a CD on Repertoire that came out this year. WT was > written by Chip Taylor, brother of movie actor John Voight. The Wild > Ones recorded it in 1965 and when Troggs manager Larry Page heard their > tape on a trip to NYC he brought the song back for the band, thinking > it'd make a good B side. It was recorded in less than 15 minutes and > the Troggs had to beg to make it an A side. (My question for David is, > why didn't you answer the trivia question and win something??) The Wild Ones were known more for their ridiculously tall, plasticized pompadours than for their music. I regret to say I've never heard their version of "Wild Thing." One of their later guitarists was Ivan Julian, who went on to play behind Richard Hell in The Voidoids. On "Wild Thing" (U.A., 1965), they were backing Jordan Christopher, a singer who was more known for his affair with Sybil Burton, the woman Richard Burton dumped in favor of Liz Taylor, than for HIS music. This all came together at Arthur's, a midtown Manhattan discotheque (in the classic sense of the term) that was briefly popular with the Jet Set. While trying to Google up a photo of The Wild Ones, I instead came across a terrific interview with Chip Taylor, at http://www.rockzilla.net/ebertowski8.html, which goes into some detail about the creation of "Wild Thing." Evie Sands fans will not want to overlook it, either. If anyone has any recommendations about the more recent albums he discusses there, I'd love to hear 'em. One of the things I most respect about Chip Taylor is his ability to write equally well in both hard ("Wild Thing") and soft ("Angel Of The Morning") modes. Another underheralded writer who fits that same bill is Sonny Curtis, whose abilities could stretch from "I Fought The Law" to "Love Is All Around," the Mary Tyler Moore Show theme song. --Phil M. -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 24 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 17:22:38 -0000 From: Kingsley Abbott Subject: Modern Doo Wop catching up a bit... The Capris had a fine album out as part of the Ambient Sound project along with The Jive 5, Randy & the Rainbows, The elegants etc. the series has been discussed before her - suffice it to say that any of the albums are well worth picking up. There was also the Ace '21st Century Doo Wop' collection in 2001 - 26 very nice tracks including Kenny vance, The Roomates and the Legends Of Doo Wop (who also had their own Ace issue around the same time). I have a spare copy of this collection should anyone want to offer something like the Kenny Vance 'Looking For An Echo' soundtrack in exchange! Kingsley RIP Teddy Randazzo - fine fine songs.... -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
Message: 25 Date: Wed, 26 Nov 2003 12:24:34 -0500 From: Joe Nelson Subject: Re: Shortest track of all time > A silent single--three minutes of silence if I remember correctly > --was available for jukeboxes at the beginning of the rock and roll > era so that diners who hated the music could have a few minutes' > respite. "Three Glorious Minutes of Silence" or something similar > was the title. May have done well in restaurants, but can you > imagine Casey playing it in his countdown show if it sold enough to > make the charts? Love it! "Three Glorious Minutes of Surface Noise and Scratch". Anyone got an mp3? Joe Nelson -------------------[ archived by Spectropop ]-------------------
End